As Prue is unconscious, he unsuccessfully tries to kill her.
With encouragement from her sisters, she uses her telekinesis in the dream world to throw him off a building, killing him.
The encounter with Mark causes Prue to change her mind about celebrating her birthday and her sisters throw her a surprise party back at the Manor.
Prue finds her sleep disturbed by strange dreams in which she is stalked and taunted by a wheelchair-bound man who is actually a sleep researcher named Whitaker Berman (Matt Schulze).
Prue casts a truth spell to find out how Andy will react to her secret.
The sisters' estranged father Victor returns, and is immediately at odds with Prue who cannot forgive him for being an absentee father.
He confesses he is trying to save the girls from the risks of having their powers by removing the Book of Shadows from the manor.
Prue sadly finds out that Andy cannot handle the knowledge of her powers and the magical parallel reality she has to deal with.
She breaks up with him while Prue and Piper vanquish the warlock before he can kill a pregnant woman whose baby is who he is truly after.
The being Yama appears and Mark throws the criminal's soul to him, sending him to Hell.